CONTEXT. JUDGEMENT. ACTION.
EDITIONBUSINESS.

Useful journalism to understand, manage and grow a business.

Search
Explore Edition Business
News · España

David Sánchez appeals his conviction and seeks acquittal, alleging a ‘prospective investigation’

The defense has appealed to the High Court of Justice of Extremadura against the nine-year disqualification from public employment or office imposed for administrative prevarication. It argues that fundamental rights were violated and that the judgment does not establish Sánchez’s specific involvement.

A judge’s gavel beside a stack of documents on a blue table.
Editorial illustration · Edition Business

The defense of David Sánchez, the brother of the prime minister, has appealed to the High Court of Justice of Extremadura (TSJEx) against the judgment that sentenced him to nine years of disqualification from public employment or office for administrative prevarication. His lawyer, Emilio Cortés, is seeking to have the conviction overturned and his client acquitted.

The appeal, which runs to more than one hundred pages, challenges both the origins of the investigation and the grounds for the judgment. These are arguments advanced by the defense, not a ruling by the appeals court: the TSJEx must examine them before deciding whether to uphold, amend or overturn the judgment.

The defense questions the origins of the investigation

Cortés argues that the proceedings amounted to a “prospective investigation” and claims that Sánchez was investigated because he is Pedro Sánchez’s brother, rather than on the basis of sufficient indications concerning his conduct at the Badajoz Provincial Council. He also alleges violations of the rights to effective judicial protection, the presumption of innocence, privacy and the confidentiality of communications.

The lawyer criticizes the fact that the investigation began following a complaint by Manos Limpias, which, as he describes it, was based on media reports. In his view, the publication of news reports is not enough to open a criminal investigation if the complaint does not provide accessible and reasonable indications of a crime. The appeal also states that the initial suspicions of possible offenses such as embezzlement or fraud were not borne out during the investigation.

What the appeal challenges in the conviction

The conviction concerns Sánchez’s hiring by the Provincial Council in 2017 and the subsequent change in the name of his position: from coordinator of conservatory activities to head of the Office of Performing Arts. The Badajoz Provincial Court found that the position had been created irregularly and that the change served his interests.

The defense responds that the judgment does not specify what Sánchez did to take part in preparing or processing the file, or how he supposedly helped to “twist the law.” It also challenges the judgment’s treatment of co-perpetration and necessary cooperation as equivalent, and denies that intent—that is, the intention to commit the offense—has been established.

The appeal also contests the collection and analysis of the Provincial Council’s corporate emails by the Guardia Civil’s Central Operative Unit. Cortés argues that those actions violated fundamental rights because, in his interpretation, they were ordered without sufficient indications. This objection is part of the appeal and remains subject to judicial assessment.

The appeal does not, by itself, change the judgment

Filing the appeal initiates a review of the conviction, but it does not amount to an acquittal or determine the outcome. The TSJEx must rule on the arguments put forward by both sides and decide the case. Until it issues a decision, the Provincial Court’s judgment remains the first-instance ruling under appeal.

The case raises questions about the limits of criminal investigations, the assessment of evidence and the reasoning required for a conviction for administrative prevarication. At this stage, it is important to distinguish between the Provincial Court’s findings, the objections raised by the defense and the decision the appeals court will issue.

Sources and methodology

  1. David Sánchez dice que le condenaron por ser hermano de Pedro, no por cobrar 340.572,36 euros de la Diputación de Badajoz sin trabajar ↗Radio Intereconomía
  2. David Sánchez recurre su sentencia y pide su absolución ↗www.rtve.es
  3. David Sánchez recurre su condena y dice que fue ... ↗www.elespanol.com
Report an error ↗

Continue exploring