Judicial annulment of Royal Decree 905/2025
The Supreme Court has annulled Royal Decree 905/2025, popularly known as the 'anti-food truck' decree, which the Government approved in October 2025 to tighten the requirements for the creation and operation of private universities in Spain. The decision, adopted by the Administrative Chamber with the unanimous vote of its seven magistrates, does not question the substantive content of the norm, but its drafting procedure.
The ruling upholds the appeal filed by the Balearic Islands and concludes that the Council of Ministers agreement of April 1, 2025, which agreed to the urgent processing of the project, did not adequately justify the extraordinary circumstances that allowed omitting the prior public consultation step. For the high court, this omission constitutes a nullity of full right, which invalidates the norm in its entirety.
A formal defect, not of substance
The core of the ruling lies in the insufficiency of the justification of urgency. The Supreme Court points out that the preamble of the royal decree "does not dedicate a single paragraph" to explaining the urgent processing and that the government agreement was limited to arguing the need for the norm to be in force for the 2025-2026 academic year.
"The only element used for justification is more of a political will for its prompt entry into force than an objective cause that proves an urgency to avoid certain effects produced by the current regulatory framework," the ruling states.
The court warns that the novelties introduced by the Organic Law of the University System (LOSU) of 2023, although they could be a source of inspiration for the reform, do not appear exposed as a reason for urgency in the Council of Ministers agreement nor in the law's memorandum. The Chamber considers that the alleged circumstances "do not allow considering that the circumstances it enumerates can be understood as extraordinary or unforeseeable".
Implications for the university sector
The annulment of the decree has an immediate impact on the Spanish university ecosystem, which currently counts 50 public universities and 49 private ones. The annulled norm established strict requirements, such as the obligation to have three doctoral programs, invest 5% of the budget in research and obtain 2% of funds in competitive contests. Additionally, it imposed the need for a favorable report from the National Agency for Quality Assessment and Accreditation (ANECA) or its autonomous equivalent, which stalled the processing of several projects.
According to ABC, a dozen university initiatives had been paralyzed after the approval of the decree, including:
- Aragon: Uniar, The Power University MBA and the Nicolo Cusano University.
- Galicia: Cesuga.
- Andalusia: Lucio Ameo Seneca and the International University of the Mediterranean.
- Extremadura: Uinde (International University of Business) and another initiative.
- Canary Islands: Technological University of the Canary Islands (Utic).
With the ruling, the ball is back in the hands of the autonomous communities, which are competent to authorize the creation of universities. The private sector, represented by associations such as Acade, has valued the decision "very positively," which unblocks these projects and eliminates requirements such as exceeding 4,500 students in the first six years of activity.
Reactions from the Government and the sector
The Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities has issued a statement in which, although it "respects" the ruling, it states it "does not share" the decision. The ministry maintains that the need for the norm "was and still is clear and urgent" and that the text "was processed with all guarantees," citing the endorsement of the Council of State.
The Prime Minister, Pedro Sánchez, stated on the social network X that the Executive "accepts the Supreme Court's ruling, but does not cross its arms." "We are already working on a new norm to prevent the university from becoming a business," he added, arguing that "the public university is under siege and the uncontrolled proliferation of private universities damages the quality of our system".
For its part, the Coordinator of Public Universities (CREUP) has criticized the Supreme Court's decision, calling it "hardly understandable" to question the existence of an urgent situation. "The speed at which new universities are being created is not a hypothetical or future issue, but a reality that is transforming the Spanish university system at a speed that requires a regulatory response," its statement says.
What to observe now
The ruling opens a new scenario for the regulation of higher education in Spain. The Government must draft a new norm that complies with legal procedures, including the prior public consultation, if it wishes to maintain quality requirements for private universities. This process could take several months, during which autonomous communities can resume the processing of stalled projects under previous regulations.